📌 3 Ways to Boost Ad Clicks

Keep This Stock Ticker on Your Watchlist

They’re a private company, but Pacaso just reserved the Nasdaq ticker “$PCSO.”

No surprise the same firms that backed Uber, eBay, and Venmo already invested in Pacaso. What is unique is Pacaso is giving the same opportunity to everyday investors. And 10,000+ people have already joined them.

Created a former Zillow exec who sold his first venture for $120M, Pacaso brings co-ownership to the $1.3T vacation home industry.

They’ve generated $1B+ worth of luxury home transactions across 2,000+ owners. That’s good for more than $110M in gross profit since inception, including 41% YoY growth last year alone.

And you can join them today for just $2.90/share. But don’t wait too long. Invest in Pacaso before the opportunity ends September 18.

Invest While You Still Can

_{Paid advertisement for Pacaso’s Regulation A offering. Read the offering circular at invest.pacaso.com. Reserving a ticker symbol is not a guarantee that the company will go public. Listing on the NASDAQ is subject to approvals.}

Most ad plays flop

Here’s the mistake:

Newsletter operators think: “If I get sponsors, I’ll make money.”

But bad ads kill great emails faster than no ads at all.

Why? Because readers are trained to ignore anything that feels like an ad.

The solution isn’t more sponsors.
It’s Sponsor–Content Fit.

When a sponsor feels like part of your newsletter, readers engage.
When it feels bolted on, they skip - or unsubscribe.

Resources You Need to Know About:

1. ​How influencers can be a Sponsor Magnet

2. 5 Strategies for a Multi-6-Figure Newsletter

3. How to use AI for a local newsletter

📊 Metric That Matters: CTR

When sponsor copy matches editorial tone, CTR lifts dramatically:

• Misfit sponsor copy → 1.2% CTR

• Sponsor voice aligned with editorial → 4.5% CTR

That’s a 275% improvement - without adding a single new sponsor.

1. The Pour Over → White-Glove Copy

The Pour Over is a Christian newsletter with millions of readers. They don’t just accept sponsor blurbs - they rewrite the copy themselves.

Advertising 

Their “White Glove” or “One-word” process optimizes ad placement:

• Advertisers receive pre-written copy and placement suggestions.

• All they need to do is say “yes” or “no.”

• Ad performance is tested and reported, ensuring repeat bookings.

• Many advertisers prefer TPO-written copy for its alignment with the newsletter’s voice.

👉 Lesson: Sponsors don’t just buy your list. They buy your voice - the vibe readers come for every time.

3 Fixes you can test today:

1. Ban raw sponsor copy. Always edit into your tone - even small tweaks lift CTR.

2. Add “why we like it.” A single authentic line outperforms 5 lines of jargon.

3. Write it like content. Tell a mini-story instead of dropping a logo.

Compare these two versions (internal vs external promo) 👇

📊 Benchmark: Local ARPU

Local newsletters with sponsor fit see ARPU (average revenue per user) that rivals national media:

• Newer markets → $3–$8 per reader

• Mature markets → $10–$15 per reader

2. 6AM City → Local Leverage

6AM City runs 31 hyper-local newsletters.

Their playbook isn’t “get as many sponsors as possible.”

Instead, they leverage community connection.

• Audience: 75% women, 35+, many earning $100K+

• Ad placement: $500–$1,500 per issue

• CTR works because ads feel like insider tips - “This BBQ spot is where locals go.”

👉 Lesson: Ads aren’t annoying when they feel relevant and empathetic.

Don’t state raw facts - tell a story that makes the sponsor feel part of the community.

3 Fixes you can test today:

1. Think “recommendations,” not “ads.” Frame sponsors as local tips: “Worth checking out if…”

2. Sell bundles, not slots. Readers need time to trust “new faces.” Offer 3-issue packages → better ROI for sponsors, stable revenue for you.

3. Use polls to tag interests. Segment readers by clicks → match sponsors with real demand.

📊 Targeting = Revenue Multiplier

Segmented lists can turn one sponsor into 10X ROI - because the ad only reaches the right readers.

3. Last Money In → Targeted Investors

Last Money In runs free investor insights. Their premium, Deal Sheet, goes deeper with accredited investors.

Hitting a unique niche attracts not just readers but companies in the space.

Big-name advertisers approaching within months is concrete proof of success.

These companies look to connect with prospects in the same market.

When Sydecar and Forge VC firms contacted Alex and Zach, it felt natural.

Some might say, “They just got lucky and sponsors found them.”

That’s true - but the deeper truth is their niche gives them an unfair advantage.

• Free list = broad awareness plays

• Deal Sheet = deal-specific ads to high-intent investors

👉 Lesson: A smaller, more targeted list often commands higher sponsor ROI. Niche uniqueness can be your leverage, not your limitation.

3 Fixes you can test today:

1. Weigh niche + competition. When starting a newsletter, factor in sponsor potential as much as content ideas.

2. Tier your lists. Keep general sponsors in your free product, deal-specific ones in your premium.

3. Swap fast. If CTR <2%, replace the sponsor. Test them like you’d test content.

💡 Tip: Don’t just sell “slots.”

Your sponsor offers can (and should) include:

• Newsletter ads

• Social promotion

• Welcome email mentions (highest open rates!)

Bundle these using the ARC framework:

• Awareness Campaigns

• Repurposing of Content

• Conversion Campaigns

Want my help fixing sponsorships?

🔑 1:1 Strategy Session

Book a 60-minute call where we:

• Audit your sponsorship placements

• Spot where ads feel “off” to readers

• Build a plan to raise CTR + keep sponsors happy

If it’s not helpful, you get your money back.

Simple. Honest. No pressure.