- EmailBreakdown
- Posts
- 📌 Inside the 3% Who’ll Pay
📌 Inside the 3% Who’ll Pay
Math behind profitable subscribers

Your Shopify DTC Brand Can’t Afford Q4 Without Zipchat
BFCM traffic costs a fortune. If your Shopify brand isn’t converting at its possible best, you’re not just losing sales — you’re burning money and shrinking Q4 margins.
Zipchat.ai is the AI Agent built for DTC ecommerce. It doesn’t just chat — it sells.
Closes hesitant shoppers instantly with product answers and recommendations
Recovers abandoned carts automatically via web + WhatsApp
Automates support 24/7 so you scale without extra headcount
Boosts profit margins in Q4, when every order counts
That’s why brands like Police, TropicFeel, and Jackery — brands with 10k visitors/month to millions — trust Zipchat to handle their busiest quarter and fully embrace Agentic Commerce.
Setup takes less than 20 minutes with our success manager. And you’re fully covered with 37 days risk-free (7-day free trial + 30-day money-back guarantee).
On top, use the NEWSLETTER10 coupon for 10% off forever.
Why most paid plays flop
Everyone loves the idea: “I’ll add a paywall and monetize fast.”
Reality: 95% of subscribers will never pay.
The real question isn’t “Will they pay?”
It’s: “Will 3% pay $100… and stick around?”
That depends less on your content style - and more on who’s on your list.
Resources You Need to Know About:
Who Actually Pays?
1. Individuals (B2C / D2C)
Price: $5–15/month
Motivation: passion, curiosity, identity (“I want to belong”).
Risk: churns fast unless the newsletter becomes a habit.
Best play: community + exclusivity.
👉 Example: Dirt Media
Early fans paid ~$500 for NFTs as membership passes.
Why it worked: felt like joining a cultural club, not buying content.
Lesson: with individuals, make paid feel like access + identity, not just information.
2. Businesses / Professionals (B2B)
Price: $20–100+/month or even $416/mo
Motivation: ROI - save time, make money, stay competitive.
Risk: only if outcomes are fuzzy.
Best play: deliverables + direct ROI.
👉 Example: Deal Sheet (from Last Money In)
Paid tier delivers private equity and investment deals.
Readers = accredited investors who expect clear financial ROI.
Why it works: one subscription can generate real returns for the reader.
Lesson: B2B readers pay more, churn less - if your content is a profit tool.
3. Authority / Reputation-driven
Price: flexible ($15–50+/month depending on perceived access).
Motivation: direct access to a trusted voice.
Risk: only works if you’ve built authority elsewhere.
Best play: leverage reputation, then layer deliverables.
👉 Example: Write With AI (Nicolas Cole & Dickie Bush)
Grew from ~20K to 45K subs in <1 year, with ~1.5K paid.
Why it worked: Cole & Dickie were already respected creators (Ship 30 for 30), books, courses).
Their authority meant people trusted them enough to pay right away.
Lesson: if you have real authority, reputation, or niche influence, paid can work much faster for you than for an unknown.
Use your reputation as the entry point, then justify the price with tangible deliverables.
🚫 Don’t guess - test first
Here’s a simple paid-readiness check you can run in 14 days:
Add a “👉 Unlock premium” CTA in your free issues.
Green light: 3–5% of openers click.
Soft-launch a founding offer to your top 200–500 readers.
Green light: 5%+ conversion.
If both signals are weak? Don’t build paid yet.
đź’ˇ Alternatives that work (and often faster)
When COVID hit, many media companies were struggling. Ad budgets froze. Readers were distracted. For most newsletters, that meant downsizing.
6AM City - a network of hyperlocal newsletters across the Southeast - decided to try something different: a one-day fundraising sprint.
The bet: if they gave readers one clear day to support local reporting, they could raise enough to keep their team strong.
What happened?
They hit 1,000 supporters in 24 hours.
Raised $40,000+ across seven cities.
Did it with no upfront costs and minimal setup.
👉 What’s your biggest blocker to monetizing right now? |
Want my help fixing this?
If you checked anything but “no blockers” - we should talk.
🔑 1:1 Strategy Session
Book a 60-minute call where we will:
Audit your list type (B2C vs B2B vs Authority)
Spot where revenue is leaking
Build a monetization plan you can implement tomorrow
If it’s not helpful, you get your money back.
Simple. Honest. No pressure.

DIY Path: Launch & Systemize in 10 Days
My course — Newsletter in 10 Days: Start. Launch. Engage. — is built to help you set up systems fast.
In 10 days (for $87.53) you’ll:
Never scramble on deadline night again
Publish consistently with ready-to-use templates for content & sponsors
Launch with strong deliverability baked in
If it’s not useful, I’ll refund you. No questions asked.
đź§ Key takeaway
Paid subscriptions succeed for three very different reasons:
Identity (Dirt)
ROI (Deal Sheet)
Authority (Cole & Dickie)
Know which one you actually have - then lean into it.
Did you learn something new today? |
Reply